Lessons from my Pinboard

While others were playing … er, learning and networking … at RWA National in 2002, I offered an on-line workshop on cataromance, based around six light-bulb lessons from my writing apprenticeship. Each had made enough impact on me to warrant a special note on my pinboard, hence the title of the workshop and this condensed article.

#1: SCENES NEED PURPOSE

We all know a story needs conflict and purpose (or character goals) and proactive characters pursuing their goals, but what about the scenes (story building blocks)? Every scene should advance the story, moving the plot and the characters toward the story's resolution and conclusion. If the scene doesn’t fulfil that purpose, then it doesn’t belong in the story. 

As a writer YOU have a scene goal or purpose. Then there is the character goal. If a scene isn’t working, isn’t compelling, is missing something, it could be this: If the character doesn't want something and isn’t prepared to ACT (proactive characters drive the story!) then the scene will lack purpose. If the character doesn't have "a plan" (NB: it can be ill-conceived and it can fail) and there is nothing stopping him/her from achieving that goal, then, no conflict. 

At the end of the scene the character either:

  • achieves his/her goal BUT… (something changes, stakes are raised)
  • fails AND… (something changes, stakes are raised).

#2: KEEP THE READER TURNING THE PAGES

Perhaps this is just a personal bugbear so feel free to disagree! While I like to see that conflict exists up front, I hate being TOLD too much too soon. I love the build in anticipation; I love second-guessing from the hints given. I like guessing the secret and I totally love that punch when the full truth is FINALLY revealed. 

Now, I’m not necessarily talking about big secrets, suspense and intrigue. This could include motivation, back-story, the vital clue to the hero or heroine’s actions.

Not telling too much back-story up front also helps keep the pace and action moving in those early chapters. Keep the reader guessing, give her an active role while reading, keep her turning the pages BUT don’t lose her by introducing plot elements from out of the blue yonder. 

Do not turn plot twists into convenient contrivances by not setting them up as plausible. You can do this using a simple rule of three: 

first mention is foreshadowing, second is reinforcing, third is fulfilling the plot purpose.

#3: HOW THE HERO/HEROINE IS DISCOVERED (a.k.a. choosing and planning the opening scene.)

There are some lines where a certain kind of scene is favored or even expected e.g. a cute meet or high action or intrigue. But no matter what the line, no matter what the tone, style, pace, the most important part of the opening scene in a romance is introducing the hero or heroine or both. 

Before you start planning that scene, before you decide which scene will open your book, think about HOW YOU WANT THAT PROTAGONIST DISCOVERED. Which characteristics do you want to show? You can’t show them all, so make sure you choose those that are key to the conflict and/or character growth and change. Oh, and it helps if the reader is instantly intrigued by and bonded with the protagonist!

Also consider WHO the reader should meet first. Whose story is this, really? Yes, it’s a romance. Yes, it’s THEIR story. But who has most to lose/gain/change? Who has the steepest character arc? Think about opening in that character’s point of view. 

#4: CONSISTENT CHARACTER VOICE

There is author voice and there is character voice, and it’s important to write deep POV (point of view) in character and consistent with character. This is something to think about when you’re adding your imagery, your sensual detail. Whose POV is the introspection in? How would THE GUY describe the scent, really? What would HE notice? Perhaps it’s just me, but I really don’t buy guys who suddenly – and inconsistently – veer into unrealistically lyrical description. I’m not being sexist. I’m talking character consistency. Same goes if your heroine is a straight-talker or a tomboy. Introspection should be in that character’s voice, the same as dialogue.

#5: PACING ISN’T ONLY ABOUT FAST

It’s also about giving the reader a chance to breathe, an easing of tension, and the contrast that is the view of the mountain from the bottom of the valley. 

Build anticipation by slowing the pace, a similar technique to that used in slow-mo in movies. For urgency and fast action, use short choppy sentences and staccato pacing. Word choice is critical. Slow down and use lusher language for breathing room for more tender scenes and emotional evocation.

Integrate setting, characterisation, emotion and sensual detail into action and dialogue. Break up the long descriptive narratives to keep the pace moving and the tension up. If you do use long introspective narratives, make sure something changes. 

#6: THE FALLING-IN-LOVE SCENE

For the resolution to be ahhhhh! perfect, the reader must believe the hero and heroine can be together, forever. Will they buy this if they’ve only ever seen them in conflict? If they don’t share any common ground? It there’s no scenes with a warmer, softer, sharing? Think about how you can SHOW they’ve fallen in love, even if the characters themselves haven’t yet arrived at the obvious! Readers love knowing that this pair will be perfect together, if only they can solve that pesky conflict that’s keeping them apart.

Include a falling-in-love scene, and some less confrontational scenes that still include conflict. They could be talking, working together, sharing a new understanding … and that may only make matters worse! BECAUSE THE STAKES ARE NOW HIGHER. I find these scenes a wonderful contrast in pace and tone which, in turn, gives the angstier scenes more impact.